By Luma Media. Updated October 21, 2026.
When patients know the surgeon and know it is AI, mostly yes. In a Mayo Clinic pilot, all 30 plastic surgery patients rated their surgeon's AI avatar trustworthy. But when an ad simply mentions AI, trust drops, according to a 2025 study of 1,276 US adults. Use a twin after trust exists, not to create it.
The Mayo Clinic pilot
Published in the Journal of Clinical Medicine in December 2025.
- 30 existing plastic surgery patients
- They watched an AI avatar of their own surgeon, and knew it was AI
- All 30 rated it trustworthy
- 26 of the 30 recognized it as their surgeon
- 7 of the 30 found it hard to tell from the real person
- 21 of the 30 said the voice sounded like their surgeon
What it tells us: patients who already know you accept a twin. Most can still tell it is AI.
Keep in mind: 30 patients is small, and all of them had already chosen that surgeon.
The JAMA study
Published in JAMA Network Open in July 2025.
- 1,276 US adults saw made-up doctor ads
- Ads that mentioned the doctor using AI, even for paperwork, scored lower
- Lower ratings for competence, trust and empathy, and less willingness to book
Keep in mind: these ads mentioned AI. They did not show an avatar.
What this means for your practice
New patients decide on trust. Existing patients want answers.
So, in our view:
- First impressions: real video
- After the consult: a twin can answer the questions every patient asks
- Recovery and aftercare: a twin can walk patients through it, in your face and voice
How to keep trust when you use a twin
- Say it is AI. The Mayo patients knew, and still trusted it.
- Use it for facts, not feelings. Comfort, results and stories stay real.
- Make the footage great. The more it looks like you, the less it distracts.
- Never fake a patient. See the rules.
Where this is going
The tools improve every few months. We expect the share of patients who cannot tell to keep rising. When it does, practices with good twin footage on file will be ready first.
See how our AI twin videos work
Questions
Do patients trust AI doctor videos?
Patients who know the surgeon can. In a Mayo Clinic pilot, all 30 plastic surgery patients rated their own surgeon's AI avatar trustworthy, knowing it was AI.
Does mentioning AI hurt a doctor's ads?
In a 2025 JAMA Network Open study of 1,276 US adults, ads that mentioned AI use lowered trust and willingness to book.
Should I tell patients my video is AI?
Yes. The Mayo pilot patients knew it was AI and still trusted it, and Meta, TikTok and YouTube have labels for realistic AI video.
Will AI avatars replace real doctor videos?
Not for first impressions any time soon, in our view. For education and aftercare, they are already useful.